Breaking Free from Commoditization

Escaping the Race to the Bottom in Payments

The payments industry has never been more vital or more crowded. While transaction volumes continue to rise globally, too many firms find themselves stuck in a race to the bottom on price. Gateways, ISOs, MSPs, PayFacs, and PayTech platforms face relentless margin compression as interchange economics tighten, competition intensifies, and technology rapidly evolves. The result: growth without meaningful enterprise value creation.

Why Commoditization Happens

Most payments firms are built around the same core value proposition—moving money efficiently and securely. Over time, this function becomes a commodity. Competing on basis points or residual splits leads to thinner margins, while rising compliance, fraud management, and technology costs squeeze profitability further. Meanwhile, high merchant churn and escalating acquisition costs make it increasingly difficult to sustain growth.

Breaking the Cycle

Firms that break free from this dynamic share a common trait: they don’t sell payments—they sell solutions. Rather than being a vendor behind the scenes, they become an indispensable part of their customers’ operations. Key levers include:

  • Vertical Specialization. Deep expertise in a target industry (e.g., healthcare, logistics, field services) allows firms to tailor workflows, compliance tools, and reporting features that generic processors can’t match. This creates higher switching costs and better retention.
  • Embedded and Integrated Payments. Embedding payments directly into software platforms—whether through proprietary APIs or white-labeled PayFac models—turns transactions into part of a broader software ecosystem, capturing more of the value chain.
  • Value-Added Services. Offering adjacent services such as invoicing, working capital, chargeback management, or analytics transforms the firm from a processor to a partner that drives business outcomes.
  • Technology Ownership. Developing proprietary infrastructure or software interfaces (instead of relying solely on legacy processor rails) builds differentiation and defensibility.
  • Data-Driven Insights. Leveraging transaction and behavioral data to help merchants understand customer trends or optimize operations reinforces stickiness and opens new monetization paths.

The Strategic Payoff

By evolving from a transaction processor to a software-led, insight-driven platform, payments firms can transform customer relationships, stabilize margins, and expand multiples at exit. Investors reward those who can demonstrate durable differentiation, recurring software revenue, and platform scalability.

The firms that will win the next decade are those that view payments not as a product, but as a strategic enabler—where technology, data, and specialization converge to deliver unique value. Breaking free from commoditization isn’t just about protecting margins—it’s about redefining the role of a payments company altogether.

Share on: